Welcome to Miscellanea — by Helena Lewandowski

HI I'M HELENA AND THIS IS MY WEBSITE
a public archive for thoughts, observations, works, readings, and anything else worth keeping.

probably the easiest way to navigate this website is to go to the archive and click whatever post piques your interest. the home page is chronological, though, and can be scrolled through like a personal journal. ORRRR hit and let it throw you into a random post!

✧ ABOUT ✧

i'm helena. i study astronomy, physics, and philosophy in boston. sometimes those things end up here. so do other things.

26 Oct 2026

do gravitons exist? and what if einstein was only MOSTLY right about gravity?

gravitons are hypothetical particles that arise from a quantum description of gravity. physicists can predict their properties and construct theories around them, although no individual graviton has ever been detected. their proposed existence raises a fundamental question: how can gravity be understood as both the geometry of spacetime and a quantum interaction?

i. the graviton, allegedly

general relativity describes gravity as the curvature of spacetime. matter and energy influence its geometry, and that geometry determines how matter moves. then, quantum field theory gives us a different language to work with. electromagnetic radiation consists of photons, and the other fundamental interactions are similarly described using quantum fields and their particles. naturally, we should wonder whether gravity can be understood this way too.

if we take small disturbances in the spacetime metric and quantize them, the corresponding particle is the graviton, a massless spin-2 boson. in the usual description derived from general relativity, it has two independent polarizations. i am trying to avoid jargon and would like this to be accessible to the average reader, so this essentially means that if gravity follows the rules of quantum mechanics, tiny ripples in spacetime would be made up of individual particles called gravitons, much like light is made up of photons. these particles would have no rest mass, and rather than literally spinning, their “spin-2” property describes how they behave under rotation. the two polarizations simply mean that gravitational waves can stretch and squeeze space in two distinct patterns as they travel. there is also an important distinction here, which is that: general relativity is a classical theory. it predicts gravitational waves, but does not, by itself, experimentally establish the existence of gravitons.

in 2015, LIGO detected gravitational waves for the first time. this was an enormous confirmation of einstein's predictions, but it was not a detection of an individual graviton. in an interview with janna levin, theoretical physicist claudia de rham explains that a classical gravitational wave can be understood, in quantum language, as an immense collection of gravitons. observing the collective wave is not the same thing as resolving one quantum. (side note - i was particularly interested in investigating claudia de rham after listening to her mindscape episode with sean carroll! beautifully worded and an interesting listen). we therefore occupy a rather peculiar position: we have observed the classical phenomenon that would correspond to gravitons, but not the quantum particles themselves, and perhaps the more interesting question is whether these hypothetical particles must have exactly the properties we have assigned to them.

ii. claudia de rham and the possibility of massive gravity

claudia de rham is a theoretical physicist whose research explores modifications to general relativity, especially working under a theory called massive gravity. 

in the conventional quantum-field description of einstein's gravity, the graviton is massless. the consequence is that gravity is a long-range interaction, extending across arbitrarily large distances even as its strength diminishes. but what if the graviton had a tiny mass?

a massive particle obeys the energy-momentum relation,

E² = p²c² + m²c⁴

and consequently cannot travel at exactly the speed of light. for a sufficiently light graviton, gravitational waves would still travel extraordinarily close to that speed, though their propagation (by propagation i mean how gravitational waves travel through spacetime, specifically their speed and whether different frequencies travel at different speeds…) could depend upon frequency. the graviton's mass would also introduce a characteristic distance scale at which gravitational behavior could begin departing from general relativity. this might initially sound like a very small modification. it is NOT.

a massless spin-2 particle in four-dimensional spacetime has two physical polarizations. a massive one has five. by introducing a mass, we introduce three additional ways for the gravitational field to behave.

historically, attempts to construct an interacting theory of massive gravity encountered serious theoretical problems, particularly an instability known as the boulware-deser ghost. a ghost, in this context, is an unphysical degree of freedom whose energy structure makes a theory unstable. in 2011, though, de rham, gregory gabadadze, and andrew tolley developed the nonlinear theory now called dRGT massive gravity, which eliminates this unwanted ghost while retaining the five degrees of freedom of a massive spin-2 field. this was important because it demonstrated that the mathematical obstacles to a consistent massive graviton were not as absolute as physicists had previously assumed. it also did not establish that the graviton actually has mass; it established that we could construct a much more credible theory in which it does.

iii. why modify general relativity in the first place?

one of the greatest unresolved problems in cosmology is the accelerating expansion of the universe. within general relativity, this expansion can be explained by a cosmological constant, usually represented by Λ. the difficulty is that the vacuum energy suggested by quantum field theory does not naturally agree with the extraordinarily small value required by our observations. this discrepancy is the cosmological constant problem.

de rham asks whether we have been approaching the problem from the wrong direction. instead of introducing an additional mysterious component into the universe, perhaps we ought to reconsider how gravity responds to the energy that is already present. in her 2020 interview with quanta, she describes this distinction using the two sides of einstein's equations. we can modify the contents of the universe, represented by the stress-energy tensor, or we can investigate the gravitational description itself. massive gravity belongs to the latter approach. if gravity behaves differently across cosmological distances, it is possible that our interpretation of the universe's accelerated expansion would change too. modifications to gravity might permit vacuum energy to affect spacetime differently from how it does in conventional general relativity.

there is, however, a problem: gravity works incredibly well exactly as einstein described it on the scales we have tested. the planets orbit properly. light bends around massive objects by the expected amount. gravitational waves arrive with properties remarkably consistent with general relativity. a modified theory therefore has to explain why we have not already noticed its modifications. one possible answer, though, is the vainshtein mechanism, through which nonlinear gravitational interactions suppress the effects of additional degrees of freedom near massive objects. the theory can consequently resemble general relativity in familiar environments while permitting different behavior on much larger scales.

but none of this means massive gravity has solved dark energy. cosmologically viable solutions remain difficult to construct, and our observations have not established a departure from general relativity. de rham discusses these limitations, alongside the theory's developments, in her 2026 paper massive gravity @ 15.

iv. how would we know?

this returns us to the existence of gravitons!!!

we cannot currently point to a single detected graviton and announce that gravity has been quantized. but we can test some of the consequences of theories in which gravitons have different properties. gravitational waves are useful here: if gravitons have mass, gravitational waves can exhibit dispersion: different frequencies would propagate at slightly different speeds. a wave traveling across an enormous cosmological distance might accumulate a measurable difference in its arrival time or waveform.

so far, observations have placed increasingly stringent constraints on such effects, without establishing that the graviton has a nonzero mass.

and even if massive gravity were supported by observations, we would not automatically possess a complete quantum theory of gravity. de rham's work principally concerns a low-energy modification of gravity; the problems encountered when quantizing gravity at very high energies remain distinct. 

i suppose the question is not only whether gravitons exist, but whether they behave as einstein’s theory leads us to expect—or reveal something his description of gravity leaves out.

26 Oct 2026, 15:04

maintained by helena lewandowski
site created: 25 august 2026, 2:11 am edt
last updated: 18 november 2026