MONOCHROMACY: LIFE IS BORING
i have been noticing that everything is becoming monochromatic, both literally and in the metaphorical sense…..
monochromacy is technically already a word, although i am using it somewhat irresponsibly here. i keep noticing how grey everything is becoming, and i don't think it's limited to objects or architecture. websites are beginning to look alike, too, and sometimes i wonder whether people are becoming less willing to be strange themselves. that last observation is harder to establish, admittedly. i have mostly been developing this theory by being annoyed on the internet.
the literal color part is not entirely in my head! the science museum group digital lab analyzed photographs of 7,083 objects in its collection and found that grey increased substantially over time while browns and yellows declined. changes in manufacturing materials presumably explain some of this, particularly the replacement of wood with plastic and metal. i was delighted to discover that somebody had actually investigated it.
cars are grey, and every newly renovated apartment seems to require white walls and grey fake-wood floors, as though there is a municipal ordinance against enjoying your kitchen! logos have had their little illustrations beaten out of them until only a company name in a geometric sans serif remains….
even places that advertise their individuality tend to look suspiciously alike. exposed brick everywhere, perhaps one neon sign if somebody is feeling particularly dangerous! (has anyone seen that millennial burger joint meme… google it if you don’t know what i’m talking about)

this might be why i keep making this website more obnoxious……… OH YEAH HELLLOOOO NEWWW UPDATE! RAINBOW LETTERS AND PIXEL ANIMALS IN THE MARGINSSSS. EVEN MORE FUN UPDATES TO COME…. JUST WAIT EVERYONNNE!!! !!!!!!
i recently read adam mastroianni’s essay on substack about what he calls the “decline of deviance,” which gave me a way of connecting several things i had been noticing separately and heavily inspired this essay. Heyyyg thank you adam!!!!! he discusses how certain forms of risky behavior have declined over the past several decades, particularly among teenagers. americans also move away from home less often (sad!). meanwhile, popular culture has become increasingly concentrated around familiar franchises, and even scientific writing appears to have become more standardized.
“deviance” is a useful word because it includes things with completely different moral consequences. murder qualifies as deviance, but so does spending four years teaching yourself to construct harpsichords despite having no reasonable market for harpsichords. i would quite like to inhabit a society with fewer murders and more unsolicited harpsichords.
movies are perhaps the example that annoys me most because i actually like movies. i know “Film” “People” will tell me that cinema peaked in 1947 and that what i really need to do is watch a restored four-hour czechoslovakian film in which a widow stares through a window for eighteen uninterrupted minutes, and sometimes (but very rarely) they are right.
there are beautiful films from the first half of the twentieth century, along with a myriad which i find boring, and my own movie sweet spot is approximately 1980–2019. this is such an enormous span of time that a person could argue it barely constitutes an opinion. i suppose what i miss is the possibility of an expensive, commercially successful movie being genuinely unusual without having to introduce itself through characters everybody already knows. i would greatly appreciate newer media with a plot that takes a little extra effort to explain.
mastroianni looked at the twenty highest-grossing movies going back to 1977 and classified them according to whether they belonged to an existing cinematic “multiplicity,” meaning an established franchise or related property. before 2000, about a quarter belonged to those categories; since 2010, more than half have every year, with the share often reaching around three-quarters under a broader definition. i occasionally enjoy a good sequel, but i don't particularly want to spend the rest of my life watching the same fictional universes expand.
this also extends to music! i recently watched carl e. martin’s brilliant video, The Gen Alpha Melody, in which he follows a particular melodic shape through an enormous number of songs. an interesting watch which i will link at the end of this post, if anyone is interested.
when writing this, i also found research by madeline hamilton and marcus pearce that offers a more specific basis for comparison. their analysis of 1,131 melodic transcriptions from top billboard songs between 1950 and 2023 identified major shifts around 1975 and 2000. they found decreasing pitch and rhythmic complexity alongside increasing note density, with post-2000 melodies tending toward smaller intervals. the researchers also discuss how complexity might have moved into production rather than simply disappeared. i think that's worth considering, given how much a musician can now do with sound.
websites tend to bother me in a more personal way, since wanting some control over mine is partly why i built this instead of making a substack or tumblr. i miss how much you could do to a page on platforms people actually used. myspace and old youtube pages could look catastrophically different from one another (if anyone actually reads this, please google what old youtube pages looked like!!!!). people changed cursors and chose backgrounds against which reading became a physical ordeal. some of these pages were genuinely terrible to use, but i would nevertheless like a little more room to make those decisions myself. i like when a page has personality and it's pretty obvious that a human made it.
mastroianni describes web aesthetics changing enormously through the 1990s and 2000s before settling into a comparatively stable repertoire of sleek layouts. i understand why practical websites would favor standardized navigation, particularly if somebody is just trying to buy a train ticket. i don't really understand why a personal website should be held to similar standards.
the extension from aesthetics to human behavior is more complicated. i am glad that many destructive behaviors have declined, particularly those that put other people in danger. i don't think there's anything charming about addiction simply because somebody might eventually write an interesting memoir about it.
however, i find it interesting how ordinary life now seems to be discussed in the language of maintenance. people monitor their sleep and track their food as though they are conducting a very long experiment on themselves. there are perfectly good reasons to care about your health, obviously. i would like my knees to work. i enjoy antibiotics.
but sometimes being a person sounds like the custodianship of an expensive object whose eventual owner will be very disappointed if you damage it. mastroianni suggests that a safer, wealthier life gives people more to lose, which could partly explain why they become more cautious. he connects this to what life-history researchers call a “slow” strategy, involving greater investment in the future.
i can see the appeal of that explanation without knowing how much it accounts for. if you expect to live until ninety, you have good reasons to consider what your life might look like at eighty. i just think it's funny how easily that future person becomes an authority over everything you do now, despite being conveniently unavailable to tell you whether they would have preferred that you occasionally enjoyed yourself.
there are perfectly practical reasons for choosing neutral apartments or familiar movies. i don't think the people making these decisions are necessarily opposed to originality, and an unusual choice can be expensive if it goes wrong. but i cannot understand the enthusiasm for decorating an entire home around the preferences of some hypothetical future purchaser. imagine disliking your own living room for ten years because somebody you have never met might eventually want to buy it.
perhaps they would have liked a green wall! perhaps they, too, are sitting somewhere grey, wondering who keeps asking for this!
i also recognize that people have different amounts of freedom to make unusual decisions. it's much easier to experiment when the consequences of failure aren't particularly serious, and an uncertain career is a different proposition when somebody else can pay your rent. i don't want to pretend that having fewer options is a failure of imagination.
still, i believe more people should engage in deviance, including me, within the enormous territory of things that might be embarrassing or impractical without ruining anybody's life. people already seem to enjoy the results. they photograph colorful houses and become attached to strange little stores that have somehow survived for decades. i particularly love bookstores whose owners have accumulated so many objects that the original purpose of the building is becoming difficult to determine.
there's a lot of affection for things that somebody spent an unreasonable amount of time making, even among people who would never give themselves permission to do something similar.
i think smaller decisions are where this becomes especially irritating. wearing something somebody might laugh at shouldn't require much justification. neither should becoming interested in a subject you will never be able to put on a résumé. spending six months on something peculiar might end with an object nobody wants, but i have difficulty accepting that this automatically makes the six months a mistake.
i keep coming back to the possibility that a person can become so good at keeping their options open that they never quite choose anything. you can spend years making decisions according to what you might someday want, or what some future employer might think, without ever doing anything particularly outrageous. i understand why people worry about those things. i just don't want to reach old age with an immaculate record of having been reasonable about everything.
some things should take too long.
Annd some hobbies should produce absolutely nothing marketable.
AAAANNNNNNDDDDD SOMEBODY Sshould write the Weird Little Book that nobody asked for.
HEY! more people should occasionally make decisions whose entire defense consists of Because-I-Wanted-To.
i want the advantages of modern safety and enough latitude to do something interesting with the years it gives me. go to the doctor! and then.. DO SOMETHING UNNECESSARY!!!!!!!!!!! decorate something in a way that makes it harder to sell.
i would like to stop feeling that every enthusiasm needs a second, more respectable purpose before i can take it seriously.. i want more color!
sources / things i was reading
the decline of deviance — adam mastroianni
the main source for the broader connection between declining behavioral deviance and cultural, aesthetic, and institutional homogenization.
pop culture has become an oligopoly — adam mastroianni
useful for the franchise / sequel data and concentration of popular culture.
for the analysis of melodic complexity, pitch range, rhythm, and note density over time.
the gen alpha melody — carl e. martin
colour & shape — science museum group digital lab
for the analysis of 7,083 collection objects and the long-term rise in grey.
07 Oct 2026, 18:37
